Artwork by Molly Howard-Foster
Showing posts with label Edward II. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Edward II. Show all posts

Saturday, February 13, 2021

Edward II, Isabella and Mortimer

One story in English history has long been the subject of public fascination. That is the 1307 to 1330 period of Edward II, his wife Isabella, her presumed lover and co-conspirator, Roger Mortimer, plus a few other characters. Some of the tales in this saga are simply untrue. Others are at least exaggerated or of questionable merit. But the whole has the modern feel of an extended lurid Sunday tabloid story, with all the attendant titillation. And with its bucket load of myths, it seems to have firmly captured the public imagination.

The brief background to the story is that Edward became king on the death of his father, Edward I, in July 1307. He was born in April 1284 at Caernarfon and was allegedly presented to the Welsh as the prince guaranteed not to speak English. This myth dates from 200 years after the event. He was 23 when assuming the throne, but had not impressed either his father or the leading magnates as having the ‘right stuff’ to be king. This was partly as he liked the practical aspects of outdoor life - digging ditches, roofing, swimming and rowing - which at the time were deemed inappropriate for a king.

Edward II

Edward was keen on another man at court, Piers Gaveston, whom he had known since he was 16. The friendship was regarded as too close by his father and others. So was Edward a homosexual? Well he wasn’t averse to women. In 1308 he fathered an illegitimate son, Adam, who died in 1322. He also likely had an incestuous sexual relationship with his eldest niece, Eleanor de Clare. He had three children later with his wife Isabella, who had been barely 12 years old when they married in January 1308. Good looking, six feet tall and very strong. he was also courageous in battle. This is as far as you can get from the effete, mincing fop portrayed in popular culture.

Question of sexuality

In fact Edward was probably bisexual, hard in an age where such a trait would not have been recognised, let alone approved. The most significant relationship he had in his life was the one with Piers Gaveston. He showed all the symptoms of infatuation, showering him with lands, titles and honours. When departing for Boulogne to marry Isabella he scandalised the kingdom by appointing Gaveston as regent of England as opposed to one of his half-brothers, or perhaps his cousin, the earl of Lancaster, which would have been customary.

Gaveston himself was married, and a father. Isabella herself became pregnant four years after the royal wedding, in 1312, when she was 16. Rather than the seemingly unnatural relationship between the two men, it was the favouritism that infuriated the nobility at the time. Gaveston made it worse by insulting and ridiculing certain leading figures, which didn’t go down well. As he controlled state patronage his attitude and behaviour riled many of the barons. They forced his exile three times - in 1307, 1308 and 1311- but on each occasion he soon returned as Edward essentially refused to accept his banishment. It all got too much for the nobility and in June 1312 Gaveston was brutally killed by two Welshmen for a group of magnates led by the earls Lancaster and Warwick.

Seal of Edward II

Edward was inconsolable and nurtured a desire for vengeance on those responsible. But fast forward 10 years. After a decade of misgovernment, battles lost to the Scots and a terrible two year famine, England was coming under the effective control of the Despenser family. Power hungry and avaricious, Hugh Despenser and his son, also Hugh, used their influence over Edward to seize lands, notably in the Welsh marches and generally to enrich themselves at the expense of established noble families. This friction was leading to civil war with the barons against the king and the Despensers. Among the rebels was the previously loyal ex Lieutenant of Ireland, Roger Mortimer, imprisoned in the Tower in February 1322, and Thomas earl of Lancaster, executed in March.

Isabella estranged

18 months later Mortimer escaped to France, with which England was sliding into war. At King Charles IV’s court he attracted a group of exiles, amid growing opposition to the Despensers. He met up in 1325 with Queen Isabella, who had persuaded Edward to let her use her influence with Charles (her brother) to try and secure peace between the countries. Her son Edward, standing in for his father in doing homage to Charles, later joined her. This proved a key piece in the game. Isabella had become estranged from her husband, who was increasingly under the sway of the younger Hugh Despenser, rather as he had been with Gaveston. Isabella repeatedly refused to return to England while Despenser was around but the king adamantly declined to remove him.

Isabella landing in England 1326

Isabella and Mortimer, with the heir, young Prince Edward, under their control, joined forces to plan an invasion of England. They were helped by William of Hainaut, who in return secured for his daughter Philippa a marriage to young Edward. With a few exiles, notably Henry the new earl of Lancaster, but fewer than 1500 men, they landed on the River Orwell in September 1326. Within a few weeks they had seized London. King Edward and the Despensers had fled. The king was forced to abdicate, with the Despensers hanged and mutilated.    

What happened to Edward?

Edward allegedly died after confinement in Berkeley castle on 21 September 1327, though it was not clear how, or if he was killed, by whom. The matter was left vague for some time. If he was murdered the later tale of a red hot poker is clearly a myth. The people named as killers were never really punished. But in fact he may not have been murdered at all as historians have increasingly used archival and other evidence (or lack of it) to question the accepted narrative. His body was not properly verified, the message of his death was not confirmed by other sources, and Thomas earl of Berkeley, in whose care he was placed, later denied in parliament that he had ever heard of any murder. Strangely Edward’s half-brother, the earl of Kent, plus Melton, Archbishop of York, with a large group, believed two years later that he was still alive. They laid elaborate and well-resourced plans to rescue him from his purported confinement in Corfe Castle. Kent was caught and executed by Mortimer very quickly for this attempt to spring an apparently dead man.


Passage at Berkeley Castle where Edward was supposedly held 

Finally a document called the Fieschi letter suggested Edward had been smuggled out to Italy and that he was being used to blackmail his son, the new King Edward. The Fieschi family was wealthy, strong in ecclesiastical circles and well connected politically. An individual named as William le Galeys in the letter (possibly the exiled king) may even have met his son, the current king, in Flanders, though this is clothed in more secrecy. The work of historian Ian Mortimer on this whole episode is both extensive and forensic and has not been effectively challenged.

Were Isabella and Roger sexual partners? Quite probably. They were believed latterly in medieval times to have been, but hard evidence has been pretty scant. Mortimer, himself married to the very wealthy Joan Geneville, clearly worked together with Isabella politically. When they ran the country as regents for the teenage Edward III for three years or so from 1327 to 1330 their behaviour was greedy and arrogant. Mortimer, circumspect at the start, later amassed lands and titles while Isabella had 30% of crown revenues paid personally to her - the highest in history. It was what we might now term a kleptocracy. Old backers deserted the pair, regarding them as no better than the Despensers they had replaced. In October 1330 what amounted to an internal coup by the 18 year old Edward and his friends removed Mortimer from power. The following month he was tried as a traitor in London and hanged at Tyburn.

Isabella in popular history  

As for Isabella she was painted for centuries as a scarlet woman, nicknamed the ‘French she-wolf’. She was said to have been party to murdering her husband, though she sent him letters and gifts while he was in captivity. Confined briefly in 1330, she then lived out her life post Mortimer in honourable retirement and relative freedom. But sentiment see-sawed more recently as she was depicted as the wronged woman, the mistreated and humiliated wife who acted with her lover to take control of her destiny. This narrative from the Mills and Boon school of history, unfortunately so beloved of popular TV programmes today, is just as much nonsense as the she-wolf routine.


Isabella in truth was just a woman of her time, driven by the culture and beliefs of 700 years ago. She guarded her royalty jealously and would have been happy to marry Edward, king of England, as royal as she was herself. She proved politically clever but should not be judged, or rather romanticised, by modern standards and cast simplistically as a stereotype, says Kathryn Warner, rightly. She had a very cruel streak and was greedy and self-serving when in power. But who wasn’t? Spurning all the myths we might be better assessing all these characters simply as 14th century Europeans.

Saturday, February 6, 2021

Not invaded since the Norman Conquest

One prevailing myth is that England has not been invaded since 1066. There have been endless incursions by Scottish and French backed forces at various times, plus attacks by everyone from Welsh neighbours to Spaniards and even Barbary pirates. But leave out the hundreds of such limited forays, stealing cattle, crops and seizing slaves. If we just focus on where, directly or indirectly, ‘regime change’ was involved, there were still five major invasions involving foreign troops. Some are unknown to many people, and school history lessons were not always energetic at covering them.

1) 1216 Louis

Arrival of Prince Louis from France

The French Prince Louis invaded with up to 700 ships. King John, quite the worst monarch in English history, had junked Magna Carta within a fortnight of it being sealed in June 1215, his move strongly supported by the Pope. Having shown he couldn’t be trusted, John resumed his old ways. The Council of 25 leading magnates which Magna Carta set up to advise the monarch decided enough was enough and encouraged Prince Louis, son of the French king Phillipe Augustus, to come to England as a replacement. Louis duly did so, with a large army. He was welcomed as a saviour, and despite Dover castle holding out against him, was proclaimed king in London.

Over half the country, including London, was soon under French rule. John fled but died at Newark, probably of dysentery, losing his baggage and treasury in the Wash. But his death rather obviated the need for Louis - John’s young son Henry could succeed without the tiresome need to redefine bloodline inheritance rules. Henry, protected by strongman William Marshall, was swiftly crowned king in October. With the main problem solved, Louis' English support rather evaporated. After a defeat at Lincoln and a naval disaster in 1217, he returned peacefully to France, a move sweetened by a £10,000 bribe.

2) 1326 Mortimer and Isabella

Mortimer and Isabella at the execution of Hugh Despenser

Another successful invasion of England, after years of chronic misrule by Edward II and his favourite clan, the Despensers. Many landed families had been robbed of property and title by the arbitrary power of Hugh Despenser and his son, to whom Edward seemed in thrall. Many of them went into exile in France, coalescing around Roger Mortimer, formerly a powerful magnate with extensive Welsh Marches lands, and a bitter enemy of the Despensers. Mortimer had escaped from the Tower in August 1323.

Edward's queen, Isabella of France, had visited her brother, the French King Charles IV, in 1325. She was later joined by her son Edward. But despite endless pleas from her husband she refused to return to England unless the Despensers - who'd contrived to confiscate her lands - were removed from power. King Edward, mesmerised by Hugh the younger, refused to do this.

Mortimer and Isabella worked together. They may have developed a sexual relationship too, though this is not certain, and in any case it is likely to have started as a pragmatic political alliance. But soon Charles was under pressure from Edward not to give succour to this obviously conspiratorial pair, so they left Paris - Isabella to her county of Ponthieu and Mortimer to Hainault. Roger Mortimer had seen his chance to use the leverage offered by Isabella and her son to put together a small mainly French force to invade England. He was backed by the Count of Hainault in return for his daughter Philippa’s betrothal to Edward’s son. Accompanied by Henry Earl of Lancaster, but counting on the support of disaffected people locally, the force of only 1500 or so landed in September 1326 at the Orwell estuary.

Within a few weeks most of the English nobility had rallied to Mortimer and Isabella, chasing the Despensers, Edward and their few supporters from London and into Wales. By the end of the year the Despensers had been caught, and after sham trials were ritually hanged, drawn and quartered, while Edward was imprisoned for nearly a year. Regime change in primary colours.

Roger Mortimer and Isabella ruled for over three years, as guardians of the young Edward III. But they steadily lost support as their behaviour in power mirrored that of the clique they had usurped. In fact their selfishness and greed soon lost them the backing of the enthusiasts who had helped oust Edward II and the Despensers. In 1330 the 18 year old son, Edward, mounted an internal 'coup' deposing (and later killing) Mortimer, cutting his mother Isabella's vast income, and initially placing her under restraint. There is still doubt about the fate of his father Edward II, but none about the son, who as Edward III reigned for 50 years in what was widely regarded as a triumph of kingship.

3) 1399 Henry IV

Henry Bolingbroke, later King Henry IV, invaded from France to oust his cousin, Richard II. The roots of their quarrel went back several years. Richard had become king on the death of his grandfather Edward III, who had reigned for 50 years. Bolingbroke was also a grandson of Edward, his father being John of Gaunt, Richard’s uncle.

Richard assumed the throne in 1377, when he was young (10) and immature. He steadily became more difficult to deal with, and pompous in his attitudes and behaviour. His cousin Henry, with whom he had partly grown up as a boy, was generally loyal and patient with him, as indeed was John of Gaunt, who had carried influence in the kingdom when Richard was younger. But Richard, convinced he’d been put in place by God, was flushed with an overwhelming sense of entitlement. His steadily worsening behaviour, rather like that of his great grandfather Edward II, lost him a lot of friends.

Matters came to a climax in 1397, when Richard moved against a powerful group of aristocrats. While such moves may have been common in medieval times, what was less so was his vengeful treatment of opponents, killing or forcing a clutch of them into exile. These next two years were later called the ‘tyranny’. Those banished included Henry. When Gaunt died in 1399 Richard disinherited Henry of the vast Lancastrian patrimony. This was to attack head on England’s richest and most powerful landed political interest. Henry was left with no alternative but to seek to recover his lands and title.

Henry, based in France but without the support of that country, set sail from Boulogne with a small force (perhaps only 500 men, mostly from Picardie) fully resolved to rid England of its unstable misfit king or die in the attempt. He landed at the mouth of the Humber on 4th July 1399. Richard, in Ireland, returned immediately. But Henry quickly picked up support from the Northern lords and from his Lancastrian heartlands, where righteous indignation at Richard’s behaviour was especially strong. Important families like the Percys rallied to him. Within 10 days he knew he had most of the country on his side.

With Thomas Arundel, former Archbishop of Canterbury advising him, Henry had himself declared King Henry IV. At his coronation on 13 October 1399, he gave an address in English, the first monarch to do so since 1066. Richard was deposed and imprisoned, but what to do with him? Not wanting a focus for opposition to the new regime, it seems he was just starved to death in February 1400 while in confinement at Pontefract Castle.

4) 1485 Henry Tudor

Henry Tudor (who became Henry VII), invaded England to oust Richard III. The background to this is well known. On the death of his brother Edward IV in 1483, Richard, whose main title was Duke of Gloucester, moved with breathtaking opportunism. He had several powerful figures, including some from his sister in law’s Woodville family, killed. He also took Edward’s sons (his nephews), one of whom was the new King Edward V. These boys, later called the ‘Princes in the Tower’, were never seen alive again.

Henry, Earl of Richmond, had a weak claim to the English throne. He was descended from Henry V’s wife Catherine of Valois, and her second husband, Owen Tudor. The last Lancastrian claimant after the civil war, he was promptly labelled a usurper. But Richard was hardly the soul of legitimacy, either, as the brother of a king who had just grabbed the throne, and who himself had almost certainly had his nephews murdered. It’s surprising that historians with a royalist bias on succession seem to forget the numerous English monarchs who either seized the crown by conquest, were themselves usurpers, or were closely descended from usurpers. Also several British monarchs were ‘unsuitable’ and simply had to be removed. The only way to do this was through death or exile, hoping there might be a son to inherit. Not always the case, of course. A major weakness, perhaps, in this approach to finding a head of state.

Even many loyal Yorkists were sickened by Richard’s behaviour. Henry, based in Brittany since 1471, gained financial and political support from a growing number of people who simply wanted to get rid of the king. Henry’s mother, Margaret Beaufort, was an influential operator, too. Descended from Edward III, she offered a route for a stronger royal claim for Henry. And importantly, she was married (her fourth husband) to one of the powerful Stanley family.

Henry was coming under pressure in Brittany, as Richard pressed Duke Francis to hand over to him this exiled figure who represented such a threat. So he moved to France, and gained some support - about 2000 mercenary French soldiers, plus some Scots. He then picked up Welsh and English supporters after landing at Milford Haven, near his birthplace, in August 1485. A few weeks later his force, though far inferior to Richard’s, defeated and killed the king at Bosworth Field. The Stanley contingent stood aside until coming late into the fray on the side of Henry. It was the start of the new Tudor dynasty, an obvious case of regime change.  

5) 1688 William of Orange 

A Dutch force successfully invaded England. Stuart King James II (and VII of Scotland), was ousted, and a new regime and government took power. The episode, often called the ‘Glorious Revolution’. had a profound effect not only on the history of England, but on the British Isles as a whole. It was also to have a big impact on wider European history.

James had succeeded his brother Charles II in 1685. He was a Catholic with close ties to Louis X1V’s France, Europe’s dominant power. Over three years he steadily became more involved in the religion-based British political struggles between Catholics and Protestants. Attempts to increase Catholic representation in the government, army and universities alienated him from both parties in England and from the Scottish Protestants. He dismissed judges opposing his demand to dispense with Acts of Parliament and also quarrelled with the Anglican hierarchy over the Declaration of Indulgence. At the same time he built up the standing army to a huge strength of 34,000, with Catholics in powerful positions. Indeed in Ireland the army was purged of Protestants.

All this was worrying, yet as James had no son the succession would be via his daughter Mary, a Protestant, married to his nephew, Dutch Stadtholder William of Orange. But things reached a crisis when in June 1688 James’ wife gave birth to a son, changing the dynamics. A new Catholic dynasty in the British Isles seemed certain. To compound the problem, Louis XIV’s aggressive moves against French Huguenots had caused up to 900,000 refugees to flee France, outraging Europe’s Protestants. The fear was of a Catholic England allied with an aggressively absolutist Catholic France.

William was an accomplished political strategist, with a wide international perspective. He convinced the main Dutch States that an invasion of England was needed and was helped in this by an invitation from seven leading English figures to free their country from James’ rule. Having expected to succeed to this throne with his wife Mary, the birth of a son to James simply accelerated William’s plan. He landed in November 1688 at Torbay, with 450 ships and 20,000 well trained and equipped troops. After a few skirmishes and the desertion of several of James’ army units and commanders, including John Churchill, William’s forces advanced to occupy London. On 23 December James was allowed to escape to France.

The 1689 Bill of Rights is the foundation of Britain’s constitutional monarchy. Catholicism would not be re-established nor would absolute power ever be held by the monarch. Various ‘Jacobite’ attempts were made by James, supported by Louis, to recover his crown. One clash was on the Boyne, 30 miles north of Dublin in July 1690. A multinational force beat James’ Irish and French troops. While the Boyne is commemorated, the more decisive battle was Aughrim in July 1691.

Some historians have had a limited, too locally British, view of this episode. William had no real interest in being king of England. But he was determined to stop French Catholic domination of Europe, so to this end having England’s resources, plus English military and trading power, were vital. The Grand Alliance he put together, including Dutch, Danish, German, Huguenot and English forces, did successfully halt French ambitions. This wider European struggle is the context in which the Glorious Revolution should be understood.

British foreign policy 

A postscript. William’s policy of alliance building to stop an autocratic power dominating Europe has been a foundation of British foreign policy before and since. Until now, as the country has abandoned it on the Brexit altar. The resulting image is of the hapless UKIP supporter, shaking his stick at the modern world and crying defiance from the White Cliffs of Dover.

Richard Weight, in his 2002 study of the modern British search for identity, says wartime politicians, historians, poets and media drew explicit parallels with the Elizabethan and Napoleonic eras. “They portrayed Hitler as the latest in a long line of jumped-up, power-crazed Continental dictators, and emphasised the unshakeable continuity of ‘the island story’”. Says the head scratching conservative writer Max Hastings, “What is remarkable is not that this thesis exercised such power over British imaginations in 1940, but that it continues to do so 80 years later”.